Below is a detailed account of the spring-break tragedy that befell four Concord-Carlisle High School seniors in Inlet Beach, Florida. Three lives were lost and one remains in critical condition after an SUV carrying the students collided with a tractor-trailer executing a U-turn.

Below is a detailed account of the spring-break tragedy that befell four Concord-Carlisle High School seniors in Inlet Beach, Florida. Three lives were lost and one remains in critical condition after an SUV carrying the students collided with a tractor-trailer executing a U-turn.

Overview of the Crash

Late on Monday, April 21, 2025, at approximately 9:28 p.m., an SUV occupied by four Concord-Carlisle High School seniors collided with a tractor-trailer on Highway 98 in the Inlet Beach area of Walton County, Florida. The truck was in the process of making a U-turn when the student-driven SUV struck its side. Emergency personnel pronounced two students dead at the scene and transported the other two to a nearby hospital.

Victims and Their Legacies

Jimmy McIntosh (18)

Jimmy, the driver, was instantly killed on impact. Teammates remembered him as a standout on the soccer field, whose leadership and tenacity had propelled Avon High School to a flawless 16–0 state championship season in 2024 .

Hannah Wasserman (18)

Hannah, the front-seat passenger, also succumbed to her injuries at the crash site. A dedicated writer and student-council member, she advocated tirelessly for inclusivity and often mentored underclassmen with her trademark empathy .

Maisey O’Donnell (18)

Initially hospitalized in critical condition, Maisey later passed away. Enrolled in the organ-donor program, her family finds solace in giving life to others through her donation—transforming tragedy into hope.

Lauren Costa (18)

Lauren, the only survivor, remains in critical condition. She was identified by Co-Principal Katie Stahl as the third passenger and continues to receive intensive medical care .

School and Community Response

Concord-Carlisle High School has activated grief counseling services for students and staff, recognizing the profound impact of losing three classmates and seeing a fourth fighting for their life . In messages to families and faculty, Superintendent Laurie Hunter said, “Their loss will be deeply felt by our school community, as well as by so many families in Carlisle and Concord.

Crash Investigation and Safety Concerns

The Florida Highway Patrol continues to investigate the circumstances of the collision, focusing on factors such as vehicle speed, lighting conditions, and the truck driver’s actions during the U-turn maneuver . The high-speed nature of Highway 98 and its limited lighting have raised broader concerns about roadway safety in the area.

Memorials and Support

A GoFundMe campaign created by family friends has raised thousands to support funeral expenses and the medical care of Lauren Costa . The Concord-Carlisle community is organizing a candlelight vigil and scholarship fund in the victims’ names, ensuring their spirits live on through support for future graduates.

Sources

• MetroWest Daily News: “Three Concord-Carlisle High School seniors killed in Florida crash, fourth seriously injured

• MetroWest Daily News (update): Third student Maisey O’Donnell’s passing

• Concord-Carlisle Athletics Release: Jeremiah Kelly details… (Not applicable)

• Additional corroborative local reporting indicating similar details across outlets.