John McNally (circa 1977 – June 2025)

John McNally (circa 1977 – June 2025)

It is with deep sorrow that the community mourns the loss of John McNally, cherished physical education teacher at Ithaca City School District and dedicated assistant coach for Ithaca College’s iconic Bomber baseball program. A pillar of commitment, strength, and mentorship, John’s impact transcended the gymnasium and dugout—shaping countless lives along the way.

A Life Dedicated to Education & Athletics

John began his remarkable tenure with Ithaca College athletics in 1996, initially serving as a student assistant coach. He graduated in 1999 with a degree in health and physical education, already demonstrating his lifelong dedication to both learning and athleticism  . After completing his studies, he transitioned into a permanent role as assistant coach, where he became the steady force behind the Bombers’ defensive excellence—coaching outfielders and guiding players at first base for nearly three decades .

Simultaneously, as a beloved PE teacher within the Ithaca City School District (ICSD), John fostered a positive and inclusive environment for young learners. At ICSD, located at 400 Lake Street in Ithaca, NY  , he championed physical wellness and instilled lifelong values like teamwork, perseverance, and self-confidence.

Impact on Student-Athletes

During his extended run with Ithaca College, John became synonymous with the Bombers. His steadfast presence in the dugout—first as an enthusiastic student coach, then as an experienced assistant—helped sustain the team’s competitive spirit and continuity. Colleagues and players alike recall John’s calming influence, technical guidance, and unwavering encouragement.

Beyond Athletics: A Community Touchstone

John’s influence went well beyond physical education and baseball. Students, teammates, and parents remember him as a mentor who truly listened, whether on the field or in the hallway. His respect for each individual reminded everyone that personal worth extends far beyond points scored or games won.

A Void Felt Across Ithaca

John’s passing leaves a profound void in both the ICSD and Ithaca College communities. Tributes from fellow educators, coaches, and alumni echo a common sentiment: a man of integrity who cared deeply, led by example, and inspired others every day.

Service & Memorial Information

Plans are underway to honor John’s life and legacy through memorial gatherings and tributes within both ICSD and Ithaca College. Details about public services, athletic tributes, and ways to celebrate his memory will be shared in the coming days.

Legacy & Remembrance

• Educator & Coach: Nearly 30 years of service to thousands of students and athletes through ICSD and Ithaca College  .

• Role Model: Encouraged excellence, resilience, and compassion both in athletics and academics.

• Community Builder: Left a lasting impact across Ithaca with kindness, mentorship, and a commitment to youth development.

A Call to Remember & Honor

As Ithaca mourns, the community also celebrates—a life lived with intention, dedication, and heart. To honor John:

• Share your memories: Whether it was a game-winning catch, a heartfelt pep talk, or a moment when he made you feel seen—let those stories be told.

• Support the next generation: In his spirit, encourage physical health, team effort, and unwavering integrity in young learners.

• Stay tuned: Official memorial details—including reception times, locations, and celebration plans—will be communicated soon via ICSD and Ithaca College channels.

John McNally’s influence will forever echo in gymnasiums and fields, hallways and classrooms across Ithaca. He leaves behind not only memories but a legacy of compassion, mentorship, and excellence.

In lieu of flowers:

Consider donating to a scholarship fund for student-athletes or supporting physical education programs within ICSD and Ithaca College Athletics. Let his passion for youth development continue to thrive.

May John McNally’s memory be a blessing to all who knew him—an enduring testament to the power of teaching, character, and community spirit.

Should you have personal anecdotes, photographs, or words of remembrance to share with the family or school district, please reach out through ICSD’s communications office or the Ithaca College Athletics Department.

Deepest condolences to John’s family, friends, students, and colleagues. May we all carry forward his commitment to making others stronger, kinder, and more purposeful.